Dr. Colin Eatock, composer
  • Home
  • About Colin Eatock
  • Composing
  • Catalogue of works
  • Writing about music
  • Eatock Daily (blog)
  • New and upcoming
  • Contact me

Stradivari, Galileo – and the Emperor's New Clothes

1/7/2012

2 Comments

 
Picture
A million dollar question?
There’s been a flurry interest in a test recently done in Indianapolis, in which old violins by famous makers from Cremona were compared to fine modern instruments. The 21 violinists who participated in the experiment were asked to try out six instruments, and to guess which were by Antonio Stradivari or Guarneri “del Gesù,” and which were recently made. (You can read about this experiment in more detail, here.)

It reminds me of Galileo’s experiment of 1589, when the scientist dropped two rocks of different mass at the same time from the Tower of Pisa. In so doing, he demonstrated that they fall at the same speed – and disproved the Aristotelian theory that heavy objects fall faster than light ones. In an instant, Galileo demolished a “well established fact” that had been widely believed for centuries.


Galileo’s initiative had a profound effect on the science of physics. But what effect is the Indianapolis experiment likely to have on the world’s ideas about violins? With the publicizing of this test, will string players finally stop mortgaging their lives so they can own a rare old instrument – opting instead to buy high-quality modern instruments at a fraction of the price? Will the best contemporary luthiers enjoy an upswing in demand for their work? And will the value of the Strads, Guarneris, et al. come tumbling down to sensible levels?

Those would all be good things – but alas, such changes will be strongly resisted. Whereas Galileo was merely upsetting scientific theory, the Indianapolis experiment threatens the financial foundations of the string-instrument business. Anyone who owns a Strad worth $1 million or more isn’t going to take kindly to the idea that it might be no better than a modern violin worth $10,000.

A little digging on the internet reveals that modern-vs.-old violin tests are not a new idea. Such comparisons have been going on at least since the 1970s – and the results often reveal the modern instruments to be as good, or even better, than highly rated old ones. (Several comparisons are described in an article that the Australian luthier Alan Coggins wrote in 2007, here.)

Yet it seems that every time such an experiment is undertaken, the methodology of the test is called into question, with the aim of discrediting the results. And true to form, the details of this latest experiment have been challenged. (See here.)

It would be interesting to see those who scorn the various tests carried out so far devise a better test, and demonstrate that it is in fact possible to consistently distinguish between the old masters and the best modern luthiers. Until then, I’m more inclined to trust the experiments that have been done (flawed though they may be), rather than the people who would have us believe, without offering any proof, that a Strad’s superior quality can be clearly heard.

However, the mystique of the Cremonese instruments is not going to die quickly or easily. There’s too much at stake.

© Colin Eatock 2012
2 Comments
leather trench coat link
9/19/2013 07:01:00 pm

nice post..

Reply
Get More Info link
10/2/2013 02:53:57 am

I admire what you have done here. I like the part where you say you are doing this to give back but I would assume by all the reviews that this is working for you as well. My kind regards.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Eatock Daily

    I'm a composer based in Toronto – and this is my classical music blog, Eatock Daily.

    When I first started blogging, Eatock Daily was a place to re-post the articles I wrote for Toronto’s Globe and Mail and National Post newspapers, the Houston Chronicle, the Kansas City Star and other publications.

    But now I have stepped back from professional music journalism, and I'm spending more time composing.

    These days, my blog posts are infrequent, and are mostly concerned with my own music. However, I do still occasionally post comments on musical topics, including works I've discovered, enjoyed, and wish to share with others.


    – CE

    Archives

    March 2022
    July 2021
    June 2021
    April 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    June 2020
    September 2019
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011

    Index

    Click here for an alphabetical list of blog entries.

    RSS Feed

    Follow colineatock on Twitter
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.