Dr. Colin Eatock, composer
  • Home
  • About Colin Eatock
  • Composing
  • Catalogue of works
  • Writing about music
  • Eatock Daily (blog)
  • New and upcoming
  • Contact me

Should Composers Be Critics?

7/26/2012

1 Comment

 
Picture
Virgil Thomson: whose side was he on?
The question of whether or not composers should also be critics is an ethical issue that’s debated from time to time. There’s no cross-industry consensus on the answer. As a result, some newspapers have firm policies against composers (or performers) writing criticism, and others don’t.

I was reminded of this never-ending conundrum when I ran across an article online about theatre people – actors, playwrights, directors – as critics (see here). And as today marks the official launch of my new CD, Colin Eatock: Chamber Music (see here), I thought it would be an apt occasion to address this issue. It will, I trust, come as no surprise for me to say that I’m basically pro-composer-critic.


Those (of us) who argue in favour of composer-critics often cite Robert Schumann, Hector Berlioz and Claude Debussy as examples of writers who enlightened their eras with their critical writing and left posterity with a rich literary legacy. We would be musically poorer today without their music, but also without their words.

Those who are skeptical of composer-critics are more likely to cite Virgil Thomson, as an example of a writer who actively courted conflict-of-interest situations to further his compositional career. My own criticism instructor, Harold C. Schonberg of the New York Times, was firmly of this view. “Before Thomson retired, he was the most performed composer in America,” Schonberg told me. “And after he retired, he was the least performed composer in America. And everyone knew why.”

Other arguments can be added to both sides of the ledger.

Composer-critics can be expected to understand the nuts-and-bolts mechanics of music in ways that few other people – even other musicians – do. They know about the different kinds of mallets that are used on a marimba, what key a harp is tuned to, and what the range of a bassoon is. Whereas performing musicians tend to have a highly specialized knowledge of their particular instrument and its repertoire, composers tend to have a broader understanding of music’s technicalities.


Moreover, composer-critics can be reasonably expected to care deeply about music. After all, it’s not as though most “classical” composers nowadays are in it for the money. Most toil over their scores with an intensity that lies somewhere between a labour of love and an obsessive-compulsive disorder.

On the other hand, composer-critics may give the impression that their musical tastes are divorced from those of the average concert-goer: that they are cheerleaders for weird modern stuff that has almost no following. Similarly, they may also give the impression that they’re so immersed in new music that they have little interest in anything written before 1900.

But are composer-critics and “critic-critics” (if you will) really so different? Whether an active musician or not, any critic worth his or her salt will have an “agenda” – an aesthetic position, and a keen sense where classical music should be going.

And both kinds ask their readership to accept them on trust – although in different ways.

The composer-critics ask readers to believe in their integrity – that they are rigorously honest in the expression of their opinions, and aren’t involved in any mutual back-scratching arrangements that couldn’t stand the light of day.

Critics who aren’t composers (or performing musicians) ask their readers accept on faith that they are exceptionally committed, knowledgeable and insightful, where music is concerned.


Such critics may hold up degrees or conservatory diplomas as proof of their musical education, and that’s all well and good. But it isn’t quite the same thing as composing a new work and saying to the world, “On this you may judge my musicality: my knowledge of musical craft, and also my sense of what is musically effective, engaging and satisfying.”

Sadly, both kinds of critic have been known to abuse their readers, and the musicians they write about. The annals of music criticism include both unscrupulous self-promoters and musically ignorant impostors.

To say that composers shouldn’t be music critics is tantamount to arguing that they should be silent in the public arena of musical opinion. In other words, they should “shut up and write music.” Yet composers who venture into criticism are willing to put their money where their mouths are. (Or, to invoke another analogy, they are prepared to cut themselves enough rope to hang themselves.) If they have something to say, and are willing to say it, they should be heard.

© Colin Eatock 2012
1 Comment
Kieren MacMillan
7/27/2012 02:10:41 am

The simple answer is this: The best critics — in any discipline — are people who write prose well and have little need to express ego in their criticisms. It is fallacious to assume that this combination of traits is bound to be either present or absent in, say, a given composer [critiquing music] or playwright [critiquing theatre].

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Eatock Daily

    I'm a composer based in Toronto – and this is my classical music blog, Eatock Daily.

    When I first started blogging, Eatock Daily was a place to re-post the articles I wrote for Toronto’s Globe and Mail and National Post newspapers, the Houston Chronicle, the Kansas City Star and other publications.

    But now I have stepped back from professional music journalism, and I'm spending more time composing.

    These days, my blog posts are infrequent, and are mostly concerned with my own music. However, I do still occasionally post comments on musical topics, including works I've discovered, enjoyed, and wish to share with others.


    – CE

    Archives

    March 2022
    July 2021
    June 2021
    April 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    June 2020
    September 2019
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011

    Index

    Click here for an alphabetical list of blog entries.

    RSS Feed

    Follow colineatock on Twitter
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.